Dylan Walsh … David Harris
Sela Ward … Susan Harding
Penn Badgley … Michael Harding
Amber Heard … Kelly Porter
Sherry Stringfield … Leah
Paige Turco … Jackie Kerns
Jon Tenney … Jay
Nancy Linehan Charles … Sra. Cutter
Marcuis Harris … Detective Shay
Braeden Lemasters … Sean Harding
Deirdre Lovejoy … Detective Tylar
Skyler Samuels … Beth Harding
Blue Deckert … Captain Mackie
Jason Wiles … Dylan Bennet
Kara Briola … Real Estate Assistant
Jessalyn Gilsig … Julie King
Cathy Schenkelberg … Waitress
David Guzzone … Male Buyer
Amandah Reyne … Woman Buyer
Carmen Mormino … Taxi Driver
Todd Cosgrove … Mailman
Tracey Costello … Sra. Rivers
Cheryl Anderson … Older Woman
Pride Grinn … Car Salesman
Sean Moran … Gus / Hardware Clerk
Jack Chang … Cell Phone Clerk
Savannah Levin … Lisa Bennet
Savannah Lathem … Murdered Child
Vitaliy Versace … FBI Agent